DALLAS ARCHIVE · COMMENTARY
Dallas High Five in 2001: Putting a Price on Lane Closures
The High Five’s low bid topped $260 million. Part of that price was for something drivers would never see in the finished ramps: keeping the existing roads usable while crews worked.
↗ EnlargeSource: TexasFreeway.com archive
Traffic kept moving between the new piers.
Looking north along US 7517-November-2002In this November 17, 2002 view along US 75, cars pass through the old interchange while cranes and unfinished columns occupy the same corridor. The photograph shows the working conditions the 2001 contract had to anticipate; it was taken after the bidding.
Original image caption
Looking north along US 75 (Central Expressway).
TexasFreeway commentary · A look back at the decisions, tradeoffs and people behind the road. Newspaper excerpts are credited beside each quotation.
01 / Dallas, April 2001
The High Five bid included a very expensive clock
Close a freeway lane, and the meter starts running. That was one of the ideas built into the Dallas High Five contract when bids opened in April 2001. Depending on the closure, the contractor could face charges ranging from $50 to $22,500 an hour. Keeping traffic moving had become an item a bidder needed to price.
Tony Hartzel’s April 4 report in The Dallas Morning News put H.B. Zachry Construction’s low bid at $260,900,383.12—roughly $46 million above the state’s $215 million estimate. The bid still needed approval. Officials attributed much of the difference to the financial risk of disrupting traffic during construction.
That gives the big number a more useful meaning. TxDOT was asking a contractor to rebuild the meeting of US 75 and I-635 while people continued driving through it. A cheaper bid with years of unrestricted lane closures would have purchased a different experience for everyone using those roads.
02 / The construction bargain
Paying for time at US 75 and I-635
TxDOT spokesman Mark Ball described the incentive plainly:
“If the contractor wants to keep the money, he is not going to close lanes.”
A charge for closing a lane encourages a contractor to consider another sequence of work, another shift or a shorter closure. Those alternatives cost money too. Bidders had to weigh them before promising a price, which helps explain why a provision intended to protect drivers could raise the initial bid.
The state also combined what had been planned as two contracts. Officials expected that change to reduce the project from eight years to five. Early completion carried a separate incentive: $32,000 per day ahead of January 2007, with a maximum bonus of $11 million. Lane availability and the overall finish date were both part of the deal.
03 / Reading the original illustration
What the High Five graphic counted
↗ EnlargeDallas High Five bids and proposed funding
The April 2001 graphic compares bids, locates the interchange and lists possible sources for the additional funding.
Staff graphic · Source: Dallas Morning News research. Individual graphic artist not identified.
The newspaper graphic places the four bids beside a list of possible funding sources. Its $10 million shortfall is a remaining funding question, not the entire increase over the estimate. The other entries include money for HOV lanes, water-line work and possible local contributions—different purposes gathered beneath one large project total.
It is a useful snapshot of a bid still being evaluated. Neither the map nor the budget list tells us how much traffic delay a particular construction decision would prevent. That was the practical question behind the hourly charges.
04 / The later photographs
The High Five beyond the bid sheet
In the November 2002 photograph above, cars pass between unfinished columns and cranes. The construction site and the operating freeway occupy the same view. That is the arrangement the contract had to make workable.
Zachry’s later project account describes an on-site precast yard and delivery a year ahead of schedule. It also lists a $288 million contract amount, rather than the April 2001 bid. Those figures belong to different stages of the project; the later account does not itemize the difference.
