Skip to content
TexasFreeway

Preserving the travel history of Texas.

DALLAS ARCHIVE · COMMENTARY

Bush Turnpike Soil Costs in 2001: The Ground Had to Stay Put

Gypsum-bearing clay complicated construction in Irving and Carrollton. Special treatment added about $500,000 per mile, and an inch of bridge movement meant a costly repair.

THE HISTORICAL CONTEXT Reporting dated
An excavated SH 161 corridor and retaining walls lead toward the MacArthur overcrossing, with cars on adjacent roads.↗ Enlarge

Collection: TexasFreeway archive

A road begins below the pavement.

Looking north at the MacArthur overcrossing12-May-2001

This May 12, 2001 photograph shows excavation at the SH 161 MacArthur overcrossing just south of I-635. It supplies context for the western corridor’s ground preparation; it does not show the reported Gateway Drive bridge repair or identify a soil treatment.

Original image caption

(high resolution 114k) Looking north at the MacArthur overcrossing, which is just south of IH-635.

Explore the May 2001 construction photographs →

TexasFreeway commentary · A look back at the decisions, tradeoffs and people behind the road. Newspaper excerpts are credited beside each quotation.

01 / Clay and gypsum

Gypsum made the usual lime treatment a problem

The Bush Turnpike’s construction problem in March 2001 lay under the roadway. Tony Hartzel reported that gypsum veins in Irving and Carrollton soil could react badly with the powdered lime normally used to stabilize clay. A treatment meant to limit movement could instead make the ground swell in cold, moist conditions.

North Texas Tollway Authority engineering director Mark Bouma put the risk plainly:

“The cure would be worse than the ailment.”

Mark Bouma, quoted by Tony Hartzel, The Dallas Morning News, March 11, 2001

Hartzel identified the problem as sulfate-induced heave. For this work, choosing the soil treatment required knowing what was mixed into the clay. The ordinary approach was no longer a reliable answer.

02 / Preparing the base

Crews treated the road base in twelve-inch layers

Newspaper cross-section compares 36 inches of treated soil under Bush Turnpike pavement with 8 to 10 inches of treated soil under typical conditions.↗ Enlarge
March 11, 2001

Roadbed treatment beneath the Bush Turnpike

The newspaper graphic compares a three-foot treated-soil base on the Irving and Carrollton segments with the shallower treatment used under typical conditions.

Staff graphic, The Dallas Morning News; data source: North Texas Tollway Authority

The authority used a liquid chemical in place of lime, treating three feet of soil in twelve-inch layers before packing it for the road base. Bouma put the additional cost at about $500,000 per mile compared with construction on more stable ground. That was an added ground-preparation cost, rather than the full price of a mile of highway.

The source illustration compares that 36-inch treated base with eight to ten inches of treated soil under typical conditions. The asphalt and concrete layers above it look similar in both cross-sections; the big difference is underneath. The extra work was buried by the time drivers arrived, but it was essential to giving the pavement a stable base.

03 / Below the pavement

The depth of the clay varied across North Texas

Geotechnical engineer Syed Haneefuddin described clay five to ten feet deep in some areas, but 25 to 30 feet deep in Irving, Las Colinas and Carrollton, with some deposits reaching 100 feet. The report also explained the role of changing moisture. Keeping moisture steady around a house foundation might be practical; doing the same around a freeway was another matter.

The May 2001 SH 161 construction photographs put the scale of the excavation in view. At the MacArthur overcrossing, retaining walls flank an unfinished corridor while traffic uses adjacent roads. The photograph shows the work area; it cannot identify the soil chemistry or establish which treatment was used at that spot.

04 / The bridge repair

An inch of movement meant rebuilding a Gateway Drive bridge

At Gateway Drive south of SH 114, Bouma said concrete structures shifted an inch after heavy bridge beams were set. The report attributed the movement to shifting soil and an inadequate foundation. Crews removed the beams, drilled a deeper foundation and rebuilt, adding up to $100,000 and a 60-day delay.

That single repair makes the engineering concern tangible. The structure could look substantial and still need work far below it. Alongside the larger Loop 9 development ambitions, the March soil story records a much smaller measurement that stopped a construction job.

Photograph viewer

Original image ↗Next collection →